본문으로 바로 이동 / Skip to content

PROOF 34

Prove.

The law of sines and the law of cosines

On general triangles.

A way to read this proof

First separate what is assumed from what is to be proved. At each step, ask which definition or earlier result permits the move. If it is unclear, return to that premise rather than skipping to the conclusion.

Definition D1

In triangle ABC, set a = BC, b = CA, c = AB, and let A, B, C denote the interior angles at those vertices.

Proof.

(1)Each side is written with the lowercase letter of the opposite vertex.convention
(2)The vertex labels can be relabeled, so what is proved for A also holds for B and C.convention

∎

Lemma L1

Let H be the foot of the perpendicular from A to line BC. Then AH = b sin C and AH = c sin B

Proof.

(1)Such an H exists uniquely.A10
(2)AH ⊥ BC, so H = C occurs only when CA ⊥ CB, that is, when C = 90°.(1), convention
(3)If C = 90°, then AH = CA = b and sin C = 1, so AH = b × 1 = b sin C(2), A9, A21
(4)If C < 90°, then H ≠ C and H lies on ray CB, so ∠ACH = C(2), A11
(5)Triangle ACH has a right angle at H with hypotenuse CA = b, and the side opposite ∠ACH is AH, so AH = b sin C(4), A4, A2
(6)If C > 90°, then H does not lie on ray CB and ∠ACH = 180° − C(2), A11, A12
(7)AH = b sin(180° − C) = b sin C(6), A4, A2, A6
(8)In all three cases, AH = b sin C(3), (5), (7)
(9)In triangle ABH the hypotenuse is AB = c and the angle at B is B or 180° − B, so by the same argument as (2)–(8), AH = c sin B(1), D1, A2, A4, A6, A9, A11, A12, A21

∎

Lemma L2

Let H be the foot of the perpendicular from A to line BC. Then BH² = (a − b cos C)²

Proof.

(1)If C ≤ 90°, then H lies on ray CB.A11
(2)If C = 90°, then H = C, CH = 0, and cos C = 0, so CH = b cos C(1), A9, A22
(3)If C < 90°, triangle ACH has a right angle at H with hypotenuse b, and the side adjacent to C is CH, so CH = b cos C(1), A5, A2
(4)B and H lie on the same ray from C, so BH = |CB − CH| = |a − b cos C|(1), (2), (3), A13
(5)BH² = (a − b cos C)²(4), A15
(6)If C > 90°, then H does not lie on ray CB and ∠ACH = 180° − CA11, A12
(7)In triangle ACH, CH = b cos(180° − C) = b(−cos C) = −(b cos C)(6), A5, A2, A7, A24
(8)B and H lie on opposite rays from C, so BH = CB + CH = a + (−(b cos C)) = a − b cos C(6), (7), A14, convention
(9)BH² = (a − b cos C)²(8)
(10)In every case, BH² = (a − b cos C)²(5), (9)

∎

Theorem T1

In triangle ABC, a/sin A = b/sin B = c/sin C

Proof.

(1)b sin C = c sin BL1
(2)0 < B < 180°, 0 < C < 180°, so sin B > 0, sin C > 0A8
(3)Dividing both sides by (sin B)(sin C) gives (b sin C)/((sin B)(sin C)) = (c sin B)/((sin B)(sin C))(1), (2), E
(4)(b sin C)/((sin B)(sin C)) = b/sin B(3), A23
(5)(sin B)(sin C) = (sin C)(sin B), so (c sin B)/((sin B)(sin C)) = c/sin C(3), A18, A23
(6)b/sin B = c/sin C(3), (4), (5)
(7)Applying the same argument to the perpendicular from B to line CA gives c/sin C = a/sin AD1, L1, A8, A18, A23, E
(8)a/sin A = b/sin B = c/sin C(6), (7)

∎

Theorem T2

In triangle ABC, c² = a² + b² − 2ab cos C

Proof.

(1)Let H be the foot of the perpendicular from A to line BC.A10
(2)If H ≠ B, triangle ABH has a right angle at H with hypotenuse AB = c, so c² = AH² + BH²(1), A1
(3)If H = B, then AH = AB = c and BH = 0, so AH² + BH² = c² + 0 = c²(1), A22
(4)In either case, c² = AH² + BH²(2), (3)
(5)AH = b sin C, so AH² = (b sin C)² = b² sin²CL1, A18, A20
(6)BH² = (a − b cos C)²L2
(7)(a − b cos C)² = a² − 2a(b cos C) + (b cos C)²A16
(8)2a(b cos C) = 2ab cos C and (b cos C)² = b² cos²CA18, A20
(9)c² = b² sin²C + a² − 2ab cos C + b² cos²C(4), (5), (6), (7), (8)
(10)b² sin²C + b² cos²C = b²(sin²C + cos²C) = b² × 1 = b²A17, A3, A21
(11)c² = a² + b² − 2ab cos C(9), (10), A18, A19

∎

Corollary C

If C = 90°, then c² = a² + b²

Proof.

(1)cos C = cos 90° = 0A9
(2)2ab cos C = 2ab × 0 = 0(1), A22
(3)c² = a² + b² − 0 = a² + b²T2, (2), A22

∎

Remark

Can A1 be removed from this proof?

Both laws come from the same perpendicular. Separate the lines that measure the perpendicular's length from the lines that add squares of lengths.