본문으로 바로 이동 / Skip to content

PROOF 180

Prove.

The determinant is the scaling factor of area

On linear maps.

A way to read this proof

First separate what is assumed from what is to be proved. At each step, ask which definition or earlier result permits the move. If it is unclear, return to that premise rather than skipping to the conclusion.

Definition D1

For A = (a b ; c d), set u = A(1,0) = (a, c), v = A(0,1) = (b, d).

Proof.

(1)Computing by the matrix action, the components of A(1,0) are a·1 + b·0 = a and c·1 + d·0 = c.A1, A25
(2)In the same way A(0,1) = (b, d). That is, u and v are the two columns of A.A1, A25

∎

Definition D2

Set det A = ad − bc. Write this value as D.

Proof.

(1)D is a number determined by the four entries of A alone.convention

∎

Definition D3

The quadrilateral with vertices 0, u, u+v, v is called the image parallelogram of A.

Proof.

(1)The vertices (0,0), (1,0), (1,1), (0,1) of the unit square go to 0, u, u+v, v respectively.D1, A1
(2)The side from 0 to u and the side from v to u+v are both u, and the other two sides are both v, so it is a parallelogram.(1), convention
(3)Let θ be the angle between u and v. Below, the case 0 < θ < π is treated first.(2), convention

∎

Lemma L1

The area of a parallelogram is the product of base and height.

Proof.

(1)A diagonal forms two triangles T₁ = (0, u, u+v) and T₂ = (0, u+v, v).D3, A12
(2)The three sides of T₁ are |u|, |v|, |u+v|, and the three sides of T₂ are also |u+v|, |u|, |v|, so the two triangles are congruent.(1), A13, A11
(3)Being congruent, the two triangles have equal area.(2), A10
(4)The two triangles do not overlap and fill the parallelogram, so the area is their sum.(1), A9
(5)Since a triangle's area is ½ × base × height, the parallelogram's area is 2 × ½ × base × height = base × height.(3), (4), A8, A21, A25

∎

Lemma L2

|u|²|v|² − (u·v)² = D², where D = ad − bc.

Proof.

(1)|u|² = a² + c², |v|² = b² + d²D1, A4, A16
(2)u·v = ab + cdD1, A3
(3)(a²+c²)(b²+d²) = a²b² + a²d² + c²b² + c²d²(1), A19, A21
(4)(ab+cd)² = a²b² + 2abcd + c²d²(2), A19, A21, A22, A23
(5)Subtracting the two expressions gives a²d² − 2abcd + c²b²(3), (4), A20, A22, A23, A24
(6)Meanwhile (ad − bc)² = a²d² − 2abcd + b²c²D2, A19, A20, A21, A22, A23, A24
(7)Since c²b² = b²c², |u|²|v|² − (u·v)² = D²(1), (5), (6), A21, E
(8)Up to this line only the four arithmetic operations were used. Area has not yet appeared.(7)

∎

Theorem T

The area of the image parallelogram of A is |det A|.

Proof.

(1)First take the case 0 < θ < π, that is, u and v not on one line.D3
(2)Taking the base as |u|, the height is |v| sin θ, so S = |u||v| sin θ(1), L1, A7
(3)S² = |u|²|v|² sin²θ = |u|²|v|²(1 − cos²θ)(2), A5, A21, A24
(4)|u|²|v|² cos²θ = (|u||v| cos θ)² = (u·v)²A2, A21
(5)Therefore S² = |u|²|v|² − (u·v)²(3), (4), A20, A25
(6)By L2, S² = D²(5), L2
(7)Since |u| > 0, |v| > 0, sin θ > 0, we have S > 0, and taking square roots of both sides gives S = |D|(2), (6), A17, A6, A18, A15, A26, E
(8)Next, the case where u and v lie on one line: if v = t u, then b = ta, d = tc, so D = a(tc) − (ta)c = 0D1, D2, A21, A24, N
(9)The image is then a segment, so the area is 0 and |D| = 0. The conclusion still holds.(8), A14, A15
(10)If u = 0, then a = c = 0; if v = 0, then b = d = 0. Either way D = 0 and the image is a point or a segment.D1, D2, A25, A24, A14
(11)Therefore in every case the area of the image parallelogram is |det A|.(7), (9), (10)

∎

Corollary C1

Swapping the two columns flips the sign of the determinant, but the image parallelogram is unchanged.

Proof.

(1)Setting A′ = (b a ; d c) gives det A′ = bc − ad = −(ad − bc) = −DD2, A20, A22, A24, N
(2)The two columns of A′ are v, u, so the vertices of its image parallelogram are 0, v, v+u, u.D1, D3
(3)Since u + v = v + u, the figure in (2) is the same as the image parallelogram of A.(2), A22
(4)The area is |−D| = |D|, the same.(1), (3), A26, T
(5)Therefore the sign records not area but the order of the two columns. The moment |det A| is taken, that information is discarded.(1), (4)

∎

Corollary C2

If a linear map scales the area of every figure by the same ratio, then |det(AB)| = |det A|·|det B|.

Proof.

(1)Theorem T concerns the single unit square. Assume the scaling ratio is the same regardless of the figure.assumption, T
(2)AB means applying B first, then A.A27
(3)The unit square becomes, under B, a figure of area |det B|, which under A is scaled by |det A|.(1), (2), T
(4)The result is the image parallelogram of AB, so its area is |det(AB)|.(2), T
(5)Therefore |det(AB)| = |det A|·|det B|(3), (4)
(6)Proof 179 verifies this identity, sign included, by entrywise computation. Area tells why the identity is natural.(5)

∎

Remark

Can A9 be removed from this proof?

Separate the line that joins two triangles to obtain the parallelogram's area from the lines that use only the algebraic identity.